Foul Gift trinket for fire

Just got this trinket, is it viable using it over Stump of Time?
I know mastery isnt that great for fire but I had the stump for nearly 8 months already and with it's low ilv would it be worse than Foul Gift?
Stump is actually a pretty crappy trinket based on the proc. (I believe I read it doesn't proc as much as other trinkets).

And based purely on stat ratings, the gift is better.

Though if you are fire, obviously mastery is not the most desirable stat.

Like myself, I have it simply because I don't need the hit from stump and because there is nothing better that I have at the moment.

But it will be the first thing I replace, even though DMC:V is lower ilvl.
Stump hasn't been worthwhile since January last year when it was hard to hit cap in T11 gear. Just about anything else that's reasonably current (378+) will be better.
or if ur like me with nuthin better to use :( fire from what ive seen theres 2 things that really captivate me and 1 is revering my rep for hyjal so i can get that rune of Zeth trink with the 458 crit.. and even if i can get something in bwd like that enraging bell of resonance.. this is of course if i dont get a lfr drop this week again. which is highly likely i wont